• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Legends Restaurant

At Legends Restaurant, situated in the heart of New Suffolk, NY, we blend the essence of sports culture with a modern American dining experience. Our passion for culinary excellence shines through in every dish, from our spirited starters like the New Suffolk Clam Chowder to our vibrant entrée salads. With a commitment to fresh, quality ingredients, we cater to diverse palates, offering many vegetarian options and exciting raw bar selections. The lively atmosphere, complete with outdoor seating and ample entertainment options, makes Legends an ideal spot for gatherings with family and friends. Join us for a memorable meal that celebrates the love of food and sport!

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Legends Restaurant, a vibrant sports bar located at 835 First St, New Suffolk, NY. If you're seeking a place where great food meets the excitement of sports, you've found your new frontline destination. This laid-back locale offers a mix of New American cuisine and beloved classics, perfect for anyone from families to friends looking to gather and enjoy good times.

Legends Restaurant provides an array of utilities that enhance your dining experience. From outdoor seating to free Wi-Fi, and even bike parking, every detail is tailored for convenience. You can take advantage of takeout, delivery, and catering options, ensuring you can savor their delicious offerings wherever you are. Plus, the restaurant accommodates all types of diners with its casual dress code, making it perfect for lunch or dinner.

One of the highlights of Legends Restaurant is its extensive starter menu. Don’t miss out on their exceptional New Suffolk Clam Chowder – a spicy, tomato-based concoction packed with clams and crabmeat, or the Savory Shrimp Beignets served with a classic remoulade sauce that will delight your taste buds. For something unique, try the Tuna Poke Bowl, a harmonious blend of cubed raw tuna and fresh ingredients that screams freshness with every bite.

  • Signature Dishes:
    • Housemade Guacamole – A creamy blend of avocado, red onion, and pomegranate seeds.
    • Burrata and Prosciutto di Parma – An indulgent experience that combines creamy burrata and savory prosciutto.
    • Ale Steamed Mussels – Rich in flavor with a hint of ale, butter, and garlic.

For those seeking a lighter option, the Rocket Salad with Beets & Goat Cheese combines fresh arugula with walnuts and honey-shallot balsamic dressing, presenting a delightful burst of flavors. Alternatively, if you're a salad lover, the Legends Salad offers a customizable approach with fresh ingredients and a choice of house-made dressings.

But don't just take my word for it; visit during their peak nights – Thursday, Friday, and Saturday – when the restaurant truly comes alive. Whether you're catching a game on the big screen or enjoying a night out with friends, Legends Restaurant is sure to be a hit with its full bar and vibrant ambiance. With offerings for all, including many vegetarian options, there's something for everyone to enjoy.

So come on down to Legends Restaurant, where the spirit of camaraderie meets the celebration of food and fun. Your next culinary adventure awaits, and I guarantee it will be legendary!

To make a reservation or place an order, call (631) 734-5123 and see why locals rave about this exceptional dining spot.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Legends Restaurant
Nicole Edmonds
Nicole Edmonds

I treated food 3 stars cause I didnt actually eat here. But, let me tell you this is one of the BEST not dive buy used to be a dive bar vibes Ive ever had. 100000010 would recommend.

John Guma
John Guma

Very nice diversified menu containing steaks, seafood, vegetarian specials, chowders and some excellent starters. Large selection of draft beer and and ample wine list. The service is first rate, friendly and efficient. Nice selection of deserts and coffee. Give Legends a try.

Mae Raynor
Mae Raynor

Love the new menu. Fair pricing for decent portions. Something for everyone and all of it delicious and known to be fresh as the owner catches a lot of the seafood herself which I find to be so cool!

Tisha Mathlin
Tisha Mathlin

Beautiful atmosphere! Food was delicious... definitely love the bar area, the game was on, there were a great vibe...

Tina H
Tina H

Meet up with two friends! Immediately ordered a Banana Old Fashion really good ! We all enjoyed our food ! Presentation was great too ! I had the clams w rigatoni which was in the specials menu. When it arrived I wasnt sure as I ...

Christopher Artibee
Christopher Artibee

First time here and so glad we came. Food and service was phenomenal! We had the wonton special for an app that was so delicious. I had seafood stew which was packed with flavor. All the various fish and shellfish were cooked to ...

Ted L.
Ted L.

Stopped by for some beers and wings. Situated near the water, the bar had a good selection of beers with a cool atmosphere and plenty of TVs. Our server Eileen was fabulous. Highly recommend.

Agatha Capacchione
Agatha Capacchione

So excited for the new iteration recently dined at the sushi counter with some friends and it was amazing. Such a welcome addition to the North Fork. Also love how they pay special attention to seafood only serving whats local and ...